Butter Boy FUDGE
Family-made since 2018 · Southern Oregon

The fudge you remember, only better.

Melt-in-your-mouth fudge made with extra butter: rich and creamy. A taste of home for some, something new for others. Pick your flavors and we'll hand-wrap 8 pieces (2 oz each) in colorful foil: a full 1 lb box for $32.

Build Your Box Join the Fudge Club
Extra butter, small batches24 everyday flavors, plus seasonal favoritesFree shipping on 3+ boxes
An open butter-yellow Butter Boy Fudge box holding 8 foil-wrapped fudge pieces, alternating gold and silver
◆

Why it’s called Butter

If you grew up with homemade fudge, one bite will take you back, only richer and more buttery. If you haven’t, get ready for something new.

Fudge is an American original, born in the 1880s. We’ve just made it better.

Melts on your tongue

Soft and buttery, each piece starts to melt the moment you take a bite.

More butter, richer bite

A higher butter content makes every piece rich and creamy, with a flavor that lingers.

Small batches, simple ingredients

Made by hand in small batches with simple, wholesome ingredients and nut butters we make ourselves.

Fresh goat milk

Made with milk from our family’s goat dairy for an extra-creamy finish.

That's why we named it Butter.

◆

Flavor spotlight

Real flavor, captured in butter: we use freeze-dried fruit, house-made nut butters, and real ingredients.

The G.O.A.T. Flavors

Always on hand

Build your box with these flavors

◆

Build Your Box

Choose any 8 pieces from 24 everyday flavors, plus seasonal favorites when they’re in season. Mix and match or double up. $32 per 1 lb box. Add as many boxes as you like.

1Pick 8 pieces2Add the box to your order3Secure checkout

Box 0 of 8Order: 0 boxesView box ›
◆

Join the Fudge Club

A fresh box every month: 6 of your G.O.A.T. favorites + 2 seasonal flavors we pick for you.

How it works

Ships monthly. Pick your 6 favorites and we add 2 seasonal flavors from what's in season.

Price coming soon/ box · delivered monthly
Boxes per month

1 box / month: price coming soon

Each box has your same 6 favorites + 2 seasonal flavors. Second box $32, third box $28, shipping included, and they all ship together on one Monday.

Club boxes ship on Mondays too, so they spend less time in transit.

Your 6 favorites + 2 seasonal flavors
we pick each month from what's in season

Tap flavors below to choose your 6 favorites (we start you with the flavors in your box).

This month's seasonal picks

Your 2 seasonal pieces come from these, skipping anything you block.

Never send me…

0 blocked

Tap any flavor you never want to get. We'll keep it out of your seasonal picks (and out of "Surprise me" above).

Quick blocks use our ingredient labels. Flavors without a label yet are matched by name only (to be confirmed).

Skip a month, change boxes, or cancel anytime on Manage my Fudge Club.
Closed butter-yellow gift box printed with the Butter Boy Fudge wordmark
Our signature gift box

Our Story

It started with my mom's old family peanut butter fudge, the special treat I loved so much that I memorized the recipe at 12. At 16 I made a batch for Bonnie as a gift. At 20 I made it again on a mission base in Zambia, where I'd been put on kitchen duty and needed a dessert. They didn't have much, but they had butter, sugar, and peanut butter.

When we moved to Oregon to help start the Abiding Place World Missions headquarters, my parents started a goat dairy nearby, and fudge turned out to be a delicious way to use that fresh milk. Money was tight, so Bonnie began selling it at the Klamath Farmers Market in 2018. She created her own flavors, and we've been improving them ever since, always reaching for the most natural, wholesome ingredients we can.

Today every piece is still made by hand in small batches, wrapped in foil, and packed like a little gift.

And the 'Boy' in Butter Boy? That's our six sons. We built this business to provide for them, and every box helps.

— Miles & Bonnie
  1. Age 12Memorized Mom's fudge recipe
  2. Age 16A batch for Bonnie, as a gift
  3. ZambiaKitchen duty on a mission base
  4. Goat dairyFamily goat dairy, fresh milk for fudge
  5. 2018Klamath Farmers Market
  6. TodayEvents across Oregon
◆

Ordering & Shipping

Fresh from our kitchen in Southern Oregon to your door.

$32

$32 per box

Each 1 lb box holds 8 individually wrapped 2 oz pieces in colorful foil (each flavor has its own color) and its own flavor label.

1 box minimum

Build one box or several. Pick all 8 flavors yourself, or let us surprise you.

Free shipping on 3+ boxes

Order 3 or more boxes and shipping is on us. Ships from Southern Oregon's Klamath Basin.

Simple shipping rates

$11.00 for 1 box, $12.50 for 2 boxes, free on 3 or more. Shipped by USPS. We ship every Monday, so your fudge spends less time in transit and is less likely to sit in a warehouse over a weekend.

Can't wait for the mail? Find us at local fairs & markets.

Questions, gifts, or event orders?

We'd love to hear from you. Corporate and bulk gift orders welcome.

Gift & corporate orders Email us